Reliable Coverage. Local Service. Lasting Peace of Mind.
Protecting families, businesses, and futures across Sheboygan and beyond with trusted insurance services for nearly 50 years.
Why Choose Key Insurance?
Trusted Coverage. Local Expertise. Personal Service.
At Key Insurance, we specialize in providing customized personal insurance, business insurance, life insurance, health plans, Medicare solutions, and group benefits. Our Sheboygan-based team understands the unique needs of Wisconsin residents and small businesses. We are committed to protecting what matters most — with policies tailored just for you.
Products
Explore Our Insurance Offerings
Key Insurance Services could easily get more than 5 stars. Working with David and his professional, kind and caring staff was absolutely fantastic!! David had a new policy drawn up in a few days with my current Insurance company and saved me a lot of money on my Auto and Renters insurance. Everyone at Keys were there to help me out in a time of need with no questions asked!! You just don’t see this happening everyday anymore!! I HIGHLY RECOMMEND CALLING TO SEE WHAT KEY INSURANCE SERVICES CAN HELP YOU WITH!! YOU WON’T BE DISAPPOINTED.
Scott W
I would just like to echo another person’s experience with Key Insurance and say that it’s a definite hometown feel working with Key Insurance. Phil, you got me such a great rate with Erie, which really reflects my lifestyle taking care of my elderly mother, and just this week, you called to check on me because your system noticed that I tried to reach you last Friday when your office was closed. Whaaaat?! lol! I was genuinely touched by your high level of service to see that my needs were being met, when I didn’t even leave you a message. Wow, Phil! Thanks from the bottom of my heart to everyone at Key. You’ve always been so thorough and kind through my years with your company. Happy Thanksgiving, everyone! Sure am grateful to do business with such a great company. Definite 5-Stars!
Karen K
Key insurance is amazing. Everyone there is super friendly and work hard to do everything they can to get you the best rate! They go out of their way for excellence. May God bless them for the amazing people that they are an amazing work they do!
Jason L
We're Here When You Need Us
From filing a claim to understanding your policy details, our support team makes managing your insurance simple and stress-free.
Local Roots, Local Commitment
Key Insurance is rooted in the hardworking spirit of Sheboygan, Port Washington, Cascade, and the surrounding areas. We believe in strong relationships, community focus, and providing dependable protection for every stage of life.Our local experts are here to help you find the perfect insurance plan.